Thinking of Going Organic? Consider Regenerative Organic
Updated: 3 days ago
What is regenerative organic farming?
You are hearing it all starts with the soil, right? There are lots of interpretations of regenerative farming, all of which can be valid if the intent of the manager is to get better outcomes both environmentally, socially, and economically. I came to regen organic from the holistic management approach (before "regenerative" was a farming term). It looks at regeneration from the point of view of entire ecosystem productivity. It is about growing more food for your livestock AND wildlife per unit of input and water. You can achieve profitability with regen organic if you master how to increase the productivity of your land per unit of input naturally. The nice thing about this approach is PRODUCTIVE agro-ecosystems build soil the fastest.
That is why it makes sense to regenerate a thriving diverse ecosystem above the ground and that will look after your soil. The result will be a healthier water cycle that will help future proof your farm, your community, and your planet. But future proofing requires profitability today or your farm business will not be around in the future to regenerate anything.
What made pristine ecosystems more productive?
Diversity of both plants and animals is Mother nature’s template for the highest ecosystem productivity. Simple perennial ryegrass systems with only a handful of species cycle nutrients rapidly. But these lack the resilience that comes from diversity that performs in weather that is outside normal expectations. They also do not build soil deep enough to reduce the requirement for inputs. While pastoral farming in New Zealand has maintained soils with some of the highest average levels of soil organic matter (SOM) found in any agro-ecosystem in the world, SOM is not increasing. The SOM in my pastures didn’t increase either in the ten years I managed pastures to optimize only perennial ryegrass and white clover. You can see twenty years of my soil test data in my new book about regenerative farming. In Sun Cheese: Lessons From Regenerative Farming, I explain why higher productivity is the key to a cooler, kinder planet and how livestock farmers can help create a more livable future. (learn more at www.restoracene.com)
Why are so many regenerative farmers destocking?
In the past ten years, I have seen many New Zealand farmers struggle to make ends meet when they decided to try regenerative farming. I could immediately see several roadblocks.
1 - Farmers are told over-recovered grass is required to build soil. It is not. It slows soil building by slowing pasture productivity.
2 – Farmers are told cover crops are required to build soil. This is not the case in perennial systems.
Several of my pastoral farm clients wasted tens of thousands of dollars to plant “regen annual cover crops” that they didn’t need. While cover crops are an excellent tool for arable farmers, even Gabe Brown says nothing builds soil better than grazed perennial pasture. My pastoral farm clients quickly learned that these crops lowered the productivity of their farms overall. Several of my clients got caught out with expensive crops that did not produce enough to feed their stock when they desperately needed the feed at the end of winter. Instead of increasing carrying capacity on their farms, many were forced to destock. This is going backwards because if a farmer wants to regenerate the health of their ecosystem, it must be more productive.
Since I had already made all these same mistakes on my organic dairy farm ten years earlier (except for the spray) and learned I didn’t need them, I tried to share that I had sequestered well over 9,000 tonnes of CO2 equivalent on my 89 hectares without these while I drought-proofed my farm. I grew a lot more pasture because if it. Unfortunately, the crotch-high yellow grass and bright sunflowers on social media were much more appealing than my not-so-sexy idea of good old pasture management.
3 – Regen minded farmers do not achieve optimal pasture recovery often enough for higher productivity because they are not on a holistic grazing plan
What does the grazing plan do that apps don’t do? The reason 99% of the farmers I meet do not grow as much pasture possible with the inputs they apply is because they use a feed budget or app to decide when to move their livestock. I often hear, “I measured the pasture and my herd can stay there for one day”. Although this feeds the herd today, the round speed that eventuates my not optimize growing the most quantity and quality of pasture for that class of stock. Will the pasture be sufficiently recovered next time the stock return to that paddock? Will it be over-recovered? Or closer to momma-bear just right? Don’t leave it up to chance. PLAN FOR IT!
A good rule of thumb in grazing management is to move stock faster when grass is growing faster in the springtime. I have seen on many farms, including our own, farmers start to optimize how fast their grass grows by providing the recovery they themselves have determined is a good period for that time of year. As soon as the farmers starts to grow more grass, they often slow the round down to achieve their desired residual, especially if they are using a feed budget app. If you keep the sheep or cattle in every paddock a little longer than your grazing plan calculations call for, the recovery times for all the paddocks ahead of you gets extended. During spring flush, this can add up to a recovery that is several days longer than the farmer he/herself had decided would be best. Yes, it is important to not lift residuals rapidly, especially in springtime, but if the round is slowed to attain a good residual instead of taking out area or adding stock to the round, the farmer falls off the plan.
A classic example of why adaptive planning grows more pasture can be seen around silage making decisons. Many farms I visit harvest too much silage or hay and end up over-grazing (returning too soon to a pasture) in summer. Feed budgets apps apparently do not prevent this because it is hard to find farmers who are not overgrazing in the summer. A grazing plan, if followed, will prevent overgrazing.
One strategy to incorporate into your grazing plan is delayed grazing. By delaying some pasture during spring flush you can achieve the best round speed for the most productivity and still keep a residual that is only a fraction higher than last year. The grazing plan even informs the farmer how many paddocks to shut up depending on your weather in real time. This is what makes it "adaptive". Then the majority of the block is kept in qood quality. Now the farmer has the option to add this area back into the round when pasture growth slows and the herd/flock need more area to achieve the pasture recovery times necessary for plants to grow as fast as possible. The plan helps optimize machine harvest decisions proactively so the farmer is not left scrambling for pasture when it is hot and dry and the machine harvested paddocks are not yet recovered.
What worked reliably in my transition to regenerative farming?
Here are some suggested practices I implemented that seemed to move me towards my desired results of more productive pastures and higher profitability in a temperate ecosystem:
Increase pasture diversity.
This can be accomplished by planting at least ten species of perennial grasses, forbs, and legumes when you re-grass. I don’t recommend combining your perennials into an annual cover crop because this will result in some bare ground the second or third year. Alternatively, you can plant your perennial mix with a nurse crop of oats at 40% of the recommended rate. Be careful to plant the larger seeds (oats and brome grasses etc.) deeper than the small seeds like timothy, clovers, and plantain. I had good responses using a grain drill to plant my oats first and then following with a pasture seeder equipped with cultipacking rollers to press in the shallow seeds. The oat nurse crop must be grazed off as soon as the perennial seedlings have strong enough roots to withstand grazing without being pulled out of the ground. You don’t want the oats to shade and kill the new seedlings. The oats just help pump sugars into the soil at establishment and reduce weed pressure without chemicals.
Graze to promote diversity.
With both your new herbal leys and your perennial ryegrass pastures, it is important to graze adaptively to promote diverse pasture. There is no recipe that will work every year. The complexity of the seasons, your cropping decisions, past events like pugging in wet springs, weather, and changes in stocking rate all require intelligent regular assessment of where you are in relation to where you want to go. That is what the holistic grazing plan is all about. It is not a “grazing system”, it is a nimble, adaptive process. That is what makes it work.
Pasture Recovery.
I only recommend lifting your pasture recovery timing and residuals gradually over the season, so you don’t stuff your quality in the spring. The quality of the grass you grow must be suited for the livestock you are running. This strategy was taught to me in 2011 by Ian Mitchell-Innes when he came to my dairy farm. A short residual in springtime makes it easier to establish pasture quality and mimics nature. Then, lift your residual just a wee bit every round going forward so by summer you can keep your soil well protected from the sun and heat. In the New Zealand context, I recommend only lifting to a summertime grazing residual no more than 5 cm higher than the previous year for cattle and 2 cm for sheep! This doesn’t sound significant but, lifting your residual by 15 cm in three years is huge. Maybe even too much. But the gradual approach allows time for your pastures to become more diverse as a result of the longer recovery times. Then the higher residuals make more sense for the sward. Also, your livestock need time to adjust to the changes so they can adapt too.
Allow recovery periods that grows the grass your stock need the fastest.
I learned that in the dairy farming context, the height of your pasture does not matter. The important thing is to give the pasture plants you want to look after the RECOVERY TIME they require. It works well to grow as many green leaves as possible before a seed head forms or before the first leaf grown on a tiller after the last grazing event turns yellow or dies. There is no need to let grasses recover past the boot stage on purpose! By using plant material before its growth slows down, animals keep plants growing quickly, just like the rugby referee keeps the game going quickly when he commands the scrum-half to pick up the ball and “use it”. Often at peak pasture growth, 18 – 25 days is enough recovery time. I have never seen a well-managed dairy pasture in either the northern or summer hemisphere that needed over 30 days recovery during peak spring flush to get to the boot stage.
Some of my clients in the UK started this grazing approach with their dairy heifers to see how it would work. Because they grew more pasture that met the nutritional requirements of their stock AND saw better animal performance, they went on to use next level grazing with their large dairy herds. That said, it is a constant struggle for me to convince all my clients that they don’t need over-recovered grass if they are trying to grow dairy cow tucker or grow replacements. Focus on growing the quality pasture your stock need!
How should you graze the delayed pasture?
Pasture growth often slows before the paddocks used for silage and hay making have recovered enough to come into the grazing round. This means a longer recovery time is needed, perhaps up to 40 or 50 days if it gets hot and dry as occurred in parts of the UK last summer. If a farmer is on the grazing plan and monitoring rainfall and pasture growth in real time, they can proactively add the delayed pasture back into the round in time to avoid returning to all the other pastures before the plants have finished their entire fast growth stage. The photo below shows my milking herd grazing delayed pasture on July 3, 2015 (equal to January 4 in the Southern hemisphere). Notice pasture is thick and green all the way to the bottome of the sward. This pasture had been shut up for one round.

It is best to strip graze delayed pastures that are headed (but still green) right after milking. Then you can shift stock on to your higher quality pasture the same day to maintain milk production. Only eat about one third of the available biomass and trample the rest if your cows are milking.
Heifers are a good class of stock to use to graze, trample, and reset delayed pasture and they can utilize more of the sward. If it doesn’t get dry and grass is still in surplus, simply get the delayed pastures grazed and trampled anyway to get them back into the round at the quality required. Then other pastures can be delayed and taken out of the round to keep the residual where you want it. This gives more pastures a chance to benefit from extra rest and grow deeper roots. In the photo below, heifers and late calvers are grazing a delayed pasture. Notice they are eating selectively and trampling this pasture that has a lot of cocksfoot (orchard grass). Basically they ate the tips of the grass leaves and licked out the clover, eating a bit over half of of the avilable forage by volume.

The photo below was taken in the same paddock thirty days later. Now the quality is good for the milking herd. Forbs and clovers have sprung up because the pasture was effectivly trampled the previous grazing to let light down to the growing points at soil level. The leaves are green all the way to the bottom of the sward. This pasture only recieved 5 mm of rain since the last grazing.

Sheep and beef farmers are benefiting from delayed grazing as well. Michael and Annette Harrex had rested the pasture on the left for longer than usual in the summer and strip grazed it with cattle. By autumn they had reset the quality nicely in what was a very dry year.

How do you know when your pasture is tall enough?
Farmers who lift their recovery periods and residual heights gradually will allow their soils and swards to improve. Over time they will be able to grow more leaves per tiller before the lower leaf yellows or the plant goes to seed. They can extend their recovery periods whilst growing green vegetative pasture. Farmers can monitor the effects on productivity of these longer recovery periods to decide how long is optimal for their context. Using a holistic grazing plan will inform the farmer when to stop lifting residuals year on year because they can monitor productivity per hectare per mm of growing season or summer rainfall.
In our “regen minds” we can imagine you could continue to lift your farm pasture covers indefinitely, but there is probably a point where you hit a ceiling unless you introduce more species of animals and plants. After all, that is how mother nature always lifts productivity to extremely high levels. Adding silvopasture elements or additional livestock species can mimic how nature achieves her cornucopia of life. Every region and farm situation is different so there is no set recipe. The important thing is to track your productivity and react proactively. You can even track your own fertilizer trials using the grazing plan because it measures production per hectare on every paddock very simply and without plating. If a fertilizer application is skipped on one paddock, the change in production between that and a fertilized pasture nearby with similar soil can be compared. Remember, the extra pasture grown must be worth more than what you spend on the fertilizer to make it worth repeating.
Allowing your stock to SELECTIVELY harvest the quality they need from the pasture allows them to grow fast and make more milk.
Like all mammals, cattle and sheep by nature are selective eaters. One mammal species never ate everything in nature. Many different species evolved to utilize the fantastic diversity of plants on offer. Even bison are selective eaters, especially when calving. They must be to acquire the nutrients they need to grow and lactate. If the feed on offer will require more energy for wildlife or your livestock to digest than they will get from it, they reject it. They are very wise after millions of years of evolution. If you force livestock to eat soiled or low-quality pasture, you will see livestock performance plummet. So how can regen farmers maintain pasture quality in the absence of the plethora of herbivore species our grasslands evolved with?
Non-selectively trample the pasture your livestock reject. Trust nature.
Our livestock know what foods will make meat and milk most efficiently. It is better to trample the rejected plant parts to the soil surface by mobbing up livestock with as many shifts per day as is practical. This lays down “green soil food” right at the soil surface where it can be used readily by decomposers and opens the sward to let light down to growing points to grow more high-quality grass. If the quality of the trampled pasture is still green, it feeds the soil livestock better. Trampling tall brown grass, especially if it is trampled in the same direction, will smother regrowth by blocking light and not providing a good C/N ratio for decomposition. We shifted our dairy herd four times a day during spring and summer to maintain quality and allow selective eating at the same time. The more rejected feed that is trampled the better, but don’t expect a diverse sward to look tidy. Different plant species will be grazed differently. Just trust your livestock.
In summer 2026, Quintin Hazlett shifted the beef cattle in the pasture on the left once a day and the mob on the right four times a day. Can you see the difference in quality that autumn? There are much fewer thistles too.

Good luck regenerating your ecosystem productivity!




Comments